Media: South Africans protest mass eviction order in court

10 09 2008

10th of September, 2008
By Toussaint Losier
Source: Bay State Banner


Residents of the informal Joe Slovo settlement and their supporters protest outside of the South African Constitutional Court in Johannesburg, South Africa. Those who gathered called on the court’s nine judges to overturn a controversial eviction order that would see all residents of the settlement forcibly removed from a township where many have lived for more than 15 years. (Toussaint Losier photo)

Residents of Joe Slovo and Delft Symphony Way, two informal settlements located in Cape Town, South Africa, pause and call for support during their train ride back from Johannesburg, where they protested the eviction order. (Toussaint Losier photo)

JOHANNESBURG, South Africa — Dancing the toyi-toyi, stomping their feet and singing protest songs, more than 100 residents of the informal Joe Slovo settlement in Cape Town and their supporters rallied outside of South Africa’s Constitutional Court last month in support of the community’s right to adequate housing.

Nearly all had traveled 28 hours by train to attend the hearing concerning the future of their community.

Inside the courtroom, their lawyers called upon the court’s nine judges to overturn a controversial eviction order that would have seen all residents of the settlement forcibly removed from the township of Langa, where many have been living for more than 15 years.

Read the rest of this entry »





Media: ‘There is no way I’ll go to starve and die in Delft’

25 08 2008
21 August 2008
Anna Majavu
Source: Sowetan

This morning an important case comes before the Constitutional Court, involving 20,000 Cape Town residents whose informal settlement is set to be bulldozed.

State-owned company Thubelisha Homes (now bankrupt), Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu and Western Cape housing MEC were granted an eviction order on March 10 this year against occupants of the Joe Slovo informal settlement in Langa.

They argued that the residents must be moved to fibre-cement shacks in a “temporary relocation area” in Delft, about 20km away from the city. They said this was necessary so that they could continue building houses as part of the N2 Gateway housing programme. After the houses were built, they said, they would move the residents back.

The community quickly established though that most residents would be left in Delft, a place many describe as “God-forsaken”, which has no rail service, where crime is rife, schools are overcrowded and medical facilities dire. Delft is also not close to any suburb where people might find work.

Housing ministry spokesman Xolani Xundu agreed that “not everyone will come back” to Langa.

He told Sowetan that 1500 families will get free houses in Langa, and 45 bonded houses will be sold to the public. The bonded houses are unaffordable to 99 percent of the residents who are unemployed. And the community of 5000 families said they did not want 3500 families to be left behind in Delft’s temporary relocation area.

Joe Slovo task team leader Mzwanele Zulu said that all the families could be accommodated if the government built RDP houses or if they worked with the people to come up with a plan that suited everybody.

Xundu said: “People who did not relocate back to Langa would be housed in Delft. They would not be left in the lurch in the temporary relocation area.”

But these claims were contradicted by Ashraf Cassiem of the Delft Anti-Eviction Campaign.

He said that hundreds of people who voluntarily relocated to Delft from Khayelitsha were still languishing in the temporary relocation area seven years later.

Leon Goliath, a civil engineer at the Cape Peninsula University of Technology, found that the temporary relocation area was “unfit for human habitation”.  Goliath said the roofs of the temporary dwellings did not connect with the walls and the gaps “led to leaks and drafts, which was not good for health … and could be a fire hazard”.

He said that windows and doors did not have frames and residents have been forced to secure them to the walls with concrete.  “These chunks of concrete could fall off and injure someone. Without proper frames, how do you lock and secure your dwelling?” Goliath asked.

He also found traces of asbestos in the fibre-cement material. Read the rest of this entry »





AEC: ‘Outsourcing of delivery no solution’

25 07 2008
July 25 2008 at 01:13PM
By Michelle Jones
Source: Cape Times

Cape Flats residents have taken to the streets of central Cape Town in protest against slow service delivery, the privatisation of housing and evictions.

The joint committee representing residents of the N2 Gateway flats, the Joe Slovo informal settlement and the Symphony Way settlement in Delft organised on Thursday’s march with the Anti- Eviction Campaign.

Their aim was to speed up housing delivery and draw attention to the problems caused by the privatisation of housing construction by Thubelisha Homes and housing management by Trafalgar Properties. Read the rest of this entry »





Press Release: City officials Restrict March by N2 Gateway Communities

22 07 2008
Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign Press Statement
July 22, 2008

On Thursday, 24 July 2008, the Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign will be leading a march to the Provincial Department of Local Government and Housing to protest the continued privatization of housing construction. Beginning at 10 am at Keizergragt Street, marchers will arrive outside the Provincial offices of MEC Richard Dyantyi to deliver a memorandum to the MEC as well as Prince Xanthi Sigcawu of Thubelisha Homes and Lloyd Nussey of Trafalgar.

Jointly planned by the various communities impacted by the N2 Gateway Project, this march bring together the residents of the Joe Slovo informal settlement, the occupants of the Joe Slovo Phase 1 flats, and the families of the Symphony Way informal settlement in Delft, along with other communities from across the Western Cape region. While each of these communities has struggled individually, this march will be their first collective action directed at the lack of genuine public participation that has been the hallmark of the N2 Gateway Project.

Over the past several months, these three communities have faced increasing intimidation from municipal and provincial officials as well as the companies to whom housing construction and management has been outsourced. Even though the residents of the Joe Slovo settlement will be challenging their forced removal to Delft before the SA Constitutional Court on 21 August, MEC Dyantyi has already applied for the rezoning of the land they now occupy – as if this community has already lost its legal appeal.

In Joe Slovo Phase 1 flats, those on a rent boycott to call attention to shoddy construction and escalating rent have begun receiving threatening letters from Trafalgar’s lawyer. And in a meeting in Osterberg last week (17/7/08), City of Cape Town Informal Settlements Manager Gregory Exford threatened representatives from the Symphony Way community with an eviction order from the Department of Roads and Transportation if they did not move from off the pavement to a Temporary Relocation Area so as to allow for the reopening of Symphony Way.

City officials also threatened to arrest the three members of the Anti-Eviction Campaign convening the march if they refused to comply with a predetermined march route. In a meeting at the Cape Town Civic Centre held on Monday, 21 July 2008, Officer Mangale from the Traffic Police refused to permit a march that included Thubelisha Homes on Lower Berg Street and Trafalgar on Bree Street along the route, citing the inconvenience to motorists, the possibility of injuries and potential damage to property. “We will make the decision whether to grant this march or not,” argued Mangale.

When the AEC members resolved to march whether or not they had a permit from the city, Officer De Graaf from the Public Order Police threatened to arrest them for not complying with the city’s requirements. After three hours of negotiations, the march conveners and city officials agreed on a route that would only bring marchers to the MEC’s office.

The Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign condemns the efforts by officers Mangale and De Graaf to limit their democratic right of assembly and freedom of expression. “The city workers are public servants. They must let the poor express themselves,” said AEC member Gary Hartzenberg.

The Anti-Eviction Campaign also condemns the ongoing efforts of city and provincial officials to push through their plans over the objections of poor people. Public participation must exist in practice, not just on paper!

The campaign also invites all struggling communities to join with the residents of Joe Slovo, Joe Slovo Phase 1, and Symphony Way on Thursday in calling for a transparent and accountable process to solve South Africa’s housing crisis.

Phansi Forced Removal! Phansi High Rent! Phansi Privatisation!

For more information:

Ashraf Cassiem 072 976 9446
Mncedisi Twalo 078 580 8648
Gary Hartzenberg 072 3925859




Press Release: AEC General Meeting Supports N2 Gateway Communities March

21 07 2008

Event: March for community control over the housing process
Time: 10am
Date: Thursday July 24th, 2008
Location: Assemble in  Keizergragt Street (march to Thubelisha, Trafalgar and Provincial Department of Local Government and Housing)

On the afternoon of Sunday, 20 July more than a dozen local community leaders came together from across the Western Cape for the first Anti-Eviction Campaign General Meeting in more than sixth months. Held at the BSL Ex-Servicemen’s Club in Silvertown, the meeting drew more than sixty delegates from informal settlements as well as public and privately owned housing. Although facing a range of different issues, from the privatization of water to a rash of night-time evictions, delegates resolved to strategise a collective way forward during the months leading up to the April 2009 elections and 2010 World Cup.

From Gugulethu to QQ section, Hout Bay to Hanover Park, delegates expressed their solidarity with the various communities impacted by the N2 Gateway Project who will be marching in Cape Town on the morning of 24 July. This includes the current residents of some 700 N2 Gateway rental flats (otherwise known as Joe Slovo Phase 1 who have been on a rent boycott since mid-2007) the thousands of families of the Joe Slovo informal settlement resisting forced removal to Temporary Relocation Areas in Delft, and the more than 200 families of the Symphony Way settlement living opposite the homes they were evicted from in Delft.

Jointly called by the residents of all three communities, Thursday’s march in the Cape Town CBD will draw attention to the problems caused by the privatization of housing construction through Thubelisha Homes and housing management by Trafalgar Properties. Marchers intend to call upon the Provincial Department of Local Government and Housing to directly see to the region’s grave housing needs. Drawing on the common concerns regarding privatization, Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign chairperson Ashraf Cassiem warned that, “The responsibility for housing, something that is usually provided for by the state, has been given to these private companies. They have a bottom line. They don’t care if you don’t have bread to feed your family.”

Delegates also found common cause with each other’s struggles, as they spoke to recent victories and pressing local issues. In particular, those in attendance called attention to the failure to upgrade of informal settlement, the needs of backyard dwellers, and “pink letters” threatening evictions and service disconnections. At one point, the delegates from the Wes Bank community in Delft spoke movingly and sometimes in tears about the problem of night-time evictions from RDP housing in Delft. Several delegates also spoke to the problem of police and councilor corruption in their areas.

In addition to a general discussion forum, Sunday’s meeting also provided and opportunity for communities facing similar problems to learn from each other. Hawkers in Mitchell’s Plain Town Centre took time to speak to those representing informal trades in Gatesville and Gugulethu. Similarly, the general meeting also brought together several delegates from the nine Cape Town Community Housing Company projects.

At the end of the meeting, delegates resolved to take the discussion back to their communities and meet again in two weeks.

For more information, please contact:

Pamela Buekes 079-370-9614
Ashraf Cassiem 076-186-1408
Gary Hartzenberg 072-394-5859




Thubelisha is now insolvent and is likely to be liquidated because of mismanagement and disrespect for poor communities

23 05 2008

Note from AEC: Poor residents all over Cape Town have long been complaining about Thubelisha Homes’ lack of consultation with poor communities and their authoritarian housing policies that resort to forced removal. Management of the N2 gateway flats have been a failure; Joe Slovo residents are exercising their right to resist forced removals next door; and now homeless residents of Delft houses have been evicted while Thubelisha gives these same BNG houses to its business friends and contractors.

Housing agent Thubelisha is R67m in the red

Andisiwe Makinana
May 21 2008 at 05:33PM

Thubelisha Homes, the government’s housing agent which was mandated to implement low-cost housing and now faces closure, is technically insolvent.

This was revealed when the company presented its performance review for the financial year (2007-08 ) to Parliament’s portfolio committee on housing on Tuesday.

The company had targeted a profit of R49,5-million and instead made a loss of R67,5-million, a variance of R117-million.

While Thubelisha had projected revenue of almost R975-million, its actual revenue stood at R338,4-million, a difference of R636-million.

Read the rest of this entry »





Province ‘to hold R300m’ from Gateway

17 04 2008

AEC Comment: Yet another instance of corruption and mismanagement by goverment. This could easily have been avoided with government officials were willing to consult with Joe Slovo residents and respected their rights as human beings to live where they have been for over 15 years.

Province ‘to hold R300m’ from Gateway

By Andisiwe Makinana

April 16 2008 at 02:24PM
Source: IOL

The Western Cape provincial treasury is withholding at least R300-million meant for the N2 Gateway Housing Project until the ongoing problems engulfing it are resolved. Read the rest of this entry »





20 000 Joe Slovo residents apply to appeal to the Constitutional Court

14 04 2008

Press Statement: Legal Resources Centre
14/04/2008

The order has been suspended by virtue of the occupants bringing an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal, which is still pending. And in the meantime the occupants have instructed their lawyers to attempt to take the matter straight to the Constitutional Court. In this regard the occupants seem to be in agreement with the Ministers and Thubelisha Homes who seek their eviction.

State owned company Thubelisha Homes, the National Minister of Housing and the MEC require the eviction of approximately 20 000 people from the land at Joe Slovo – a well positioned piece of land fairly close to the city. The purpose of the evictions, they argue, is to rehabilitate the land for the Gateway housing programme, which is government’s biggest housing project in the Western Cape.

They have offered the evictees alternative accommodation at Delft approximately 20 kms away from Joe Slovo and further away from the city and it’s employment opportunities. This means, and has been proven as such that transport, crime and unemployment are serious problems at Delft.

In his judgement Judge Hlophe dismissed the resident’s contention that they are living on the land with the consent of the city. He held that they are illegal occupants and are subject to the provisions of the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from the Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE). He further held that as they were illegal occupants they could not claim that they have a legitimate substantive expectation to see that their housing rights are realised at Joe Slovo on the basis of a promise made by officials that 70% of the houses would be allocated to current residents.

The Judge also held that Thubelisha Homes and the Ministers had complied with all the requirements of the Prevention of Illega Evictions from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE).

In his affidavit outlining their appeal case, Mayenzeke Sopaqa, a leader of the Joe Slovo community, stated that the residents would prefer that the matter go directly to the Constitutional Court, as the matter would inevitably reach the Constitutional Court after a hearing at the Supreme Court of Appeal. This would also result in the matter being resolved quicker and with less expense. He submits that Judge Hlophe’s judgment was wrong in a number of respects. He asserts that the Judge was wrong in finding that they had not shown that they had the consent of the city to live on the land, as they have received services from and engaged with the City for more than a decade. And that not only did they have consent, but that in evicting them the Judge ignored their substantive legitimate expectations and that to do so is a breach of their rights. Sopaqa further avers that the occupants have shown that the applicant company and Ministers failed to comply with the provisions of PIE; and also failed to properly describe the land and site from which they seek the eviction of these 20 000 black occupants – the poorest people closest to the city of Cape Town.

The current housing crisis in Cape Town, and South Africa as a whole requires that state policies pass constitutional scrutiny so that some of the most vulnerable members of our society are adequately protected and treated with dignity.





Solidarity: Thubelisha strikes again….

2 04 2008
The Herald 2/4/2008

Shack dwellers upset over delays in RDP housing completion

Katherine Wilkinson GARDEN ROUTE CORRESPONDENT

PROSPECTIVE RDP housing recipients in Mossel Bay remain extremely unhappy and anxious about the lack of building progress, even after a meeting was held on Monday night in an attempt to alleviate the situation.

Community members broke down their shacks in June and July last year as requested to make space for RDP houses. Families then constructed smaller, temporary, one-room shacks on the edges of the stands, to have somewhere to live while their RDP houses were being built.

Mossel Bay Ward 2 committee member Ernest Kanana said: “Not a single house has been completely finished since July last year and many houses are already cracked.”

He estimated there were about 100 houses and said the families for whom the houses were intended were still squashed into one- room shacks, which provided no privacy.

Thobeka Beyi, one of the housing recipients, said: “My new RDP house has two holes in the roof. Soon it will be winter and it will be raining, and there are old people here as well.”

Municipal housing, environment, sport and facilities head Johan van Zyl said: “We are also anxious and find ourselves in a predicament.”

He said Thubelisha Homes was an agency appointed by the government to assist municipalities with delivery of RDP houses and Thubelisha had, in turn, appointed Ujima Contractors to build the houses.

“The two companies are in a legal dispute, so now there is a stand-off. The council has assurance from Thubelisha that the project will continue and that houses will be completed, but not on time.”

He said the council was not party to Thubelisha‘s contract with Ujima Contractors.

Thubelisha Homes spokesman Xolani Tyilana said: “Thubelisha Homes was appointed by the Mossel Bay municipality to manage the building of RDP houses for the community of Elangeni. The houses were to be built on the same plots where people‘s shacks were. People were never asked to vacate their plots at any stage.

“Thubelisha appointed a contractor to build the houses. The contractor under-performed and Thubelisha had no choice but to terminate its services.

“We hope that by the end of this month the new contractor will be on site. We urge the people to stay where they lived before, and not to move anywhere else until advised by Thubelisha Homes, the Mossel Bay municipality or the new contractor.”





AEC Press Release: N2 Gateway Residents Committee

27 03 2008
27 March 2008 at 10:30am
LANGA, CAPE TOWN – Angry First Phase N2 Gateway Flats residents from Langa are calling on the media to attend their meeting tonight (27 March 2008) with the development company that funded Thubelisha Homes to build the defective flats they are staying in.
The meeting will take place at the Langa Sports Complex from 6:30pm – 8:30pm.
The N2 Gateway flats residents have been boycotting rent payments since June 2007, after the company failed to repair the massive defects in their flats. These defects included huge cracks in walls, and leaking roofs to the extent that rooms became unliveable and parents had to send their children away to live with extended family members. There was also a problem since the residents moved in, in September 2006 that anybody’s keys could open anyone else’s flats. The company refused to change the locks and the residents were spending a lot of money changing locks and repairing defects on these rental properties.
The Committee has tried to solve the current impasse by suggesting to the company that they pay a committment fee of between R250 and R690 per month for three months, in exchange for which they expect the company to repair all the flats to a liveable standard, and to change the management team. The current management team is useless, according to the N2 Gateway Residents Committee.
However, the company agreed to this in a small meeting but then when it came to reporting back to the community, they announced that they wanted a much higher amount. The community was not prepared to pay this, given that they will also pay back rental arrears once the flats have been repaired.
The N2 Gateway Residents Committee is angered that the company is not taking them seriously. The N2 Gateway Residents Committee has gone out of their way to solve problems that are not their responsibility. The community understood from the glossy newspaper adverts that this national flagship project was providing well built flats that were ready for occupation, and that all the tenants had to do was pay their rent and move in. However they soon saw that once again, the poor were being taken for a ride. As with all other low cost housing projects in the city, the developers made a huge profit by using cheap and substandard building materials and by cutting corners (i.e. not providing individual keys and locks for the flats), thereby showing their disrespect for poor and working class Black citizens.
The N2 Gateway Residents Committee also supports the Joe Slovo community, which is currently appealing against a forced removal court order handed down by Judge Hlophe.
For more information, please call Luthando Ndabambi, N2 Gateway Residents Committee Co-ordinator on 079 8966126







Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 607 other followers